I.
When I first became interested in livestock herders in parts of Africa, I was told they lived on marginal lands (or worse). Half a century later, the refrain is the herders are marginalized–marginalized (or worse) in politics, by the larger economy, and now because of the climate emergency. I hate that word, “marginal.” Even when pastoralists are commended as models for adaptability, they’re made to sound like hardy little tardigrades–again, marginal–that survive in some of the most hostile environments on the planet.
–But marginal does not mean ephemeral. In fact, pastoralists just keep on going as a global infrastructure producing options under uncertain Anthropocene conditions.
Yes, many pastoralists are pushed to the edge of abandonment by all manner of encroachment and extraction. It is also true that policymakers keep searching for optimal policies when the multiplicity of pastoralisms require a spectrum of different ones. To talk of pastoralist development is immediately to talk about a range of strategies. Not just because any one policy has its implementation and execution modified in light of context. It is also because we cannot rely on actually dismantling macro-structures and aiming for Big-T transformations. Rethinking development in terms of repair, decentering design solutionism, and disrupting urban biases are required as well. The language of “success” gives way to really-existing accomplishments.
–Indeed, we have to push rethinking further. For one thing, we shouldn’t be surprised by the huge variety in pastoralist organizational and network formats required for addressing real-time matches between their contingent task demands and their contingent capabilities: associations, dedicated government agencies, designated government officers, social movements, catchment areas and planning regions, group ranches and cooperatives, conservancies, coordinators and liaisons, consortia, councils, cross-border committees, NGOs, INGOs, and more. Such requisite variety is to be expected and accommodated.
Nor is it unexpected that a premium is placed on having personal and professional contacts and relationships, since formal and ad hoc structures for organizational and network diversity can only go so far. This applies not just to the pastoralists but also to anyone in their networks. A government field officer or headquarters official can also be a mediating, focal player during the and in immediate response thereafter. It is grotesquely misleading to reduce this complexity and diversity to an abstracted “politics” rather than context-specific requisite variety being searched for and actually demonstrated.
II.
200 million to 500 million pastoralist herders in the world is a very large number, and very large numbers have distributions ranging from those doing better to those doing worse than average. It’s fair then to ask those who argue that pastoralist societies are changing for the worse, which ones in the distribution of pastoralist communities are “getting it (more) right,” from the perspective(s) of the critics.
–The fact is that no one, let alone those insisting pastoralist societies are being depastoralized by forces beyond their control, has an overall understanding of the empirical distribution of pastoralist societies worldwide. Instead, “our critical project is to increase understanding of those pastoralist societies we study.”
And significant advances have been made in that understanding. Clearly, there have been pastoralist societies which have ceased to practice any variety of pastoralism. Persistently failing development projects, misleading assumptions about pastoralist behavior, and basically wrong middle-level theories (think the Tragedy of the Commons in light of the subsequent Common Property Resource Management case material) are now a shared knowledge base, and continue to be so even though incentives remain among donors and governments to ignore it.
–But there are problems with “our critical project is to increase understanding of pastoralist societies.” First, if there were ever a Eurocentric idea it is that one. It’s passing odd when critics of Eurocentrism commit themselves to increased understanding and reflection tout court.
Second, it’s no news that others, including pastoralists themselves, want more by way of response and action from better understanding. Where are the counternarratives upon which to base better policy and management not only to “pastoralists are backwards and therefore [sic] in need to techno-managerial solutions”, but also to ”pastoralist societies are being depastoralized” by wider processes including commodification, marketization, financialization, settler colonialism, nationalism, militarism, racism, marginalization, the climate emergency, and always-late capitalism? As the common property resource management narrative is no longer sufficient to base some policy and management, what are robust alternatives?
Third, those counternarratives have to be at the level of actionable granularity rather than de rigueur calls for big-T transformations, whose details are to be left to, well, the low and mean cunning of others who know better than the critics how to get their hands dirty. It’s also more than passing odd that those who rightly fault government policies and projects should at the same time not develop counternarrative policies and strategies to test and validate their increased understanding of what is actually underway on the ground.
–Some already know and act upon the above, but still: So what?
It seems to me that we are at a conjuncture similar to that Elinor Ostrom and her colleagues found themselves in at the 1985 Annapolis Conference on Common Property Resource Management. There she worked with researchers who had presented case material finding too many empirical and policy shortfalls in the Tragedy of Commons and government rural management policies.
From that conference and subsequent work came the counternarrative for which she later won the Nobel Prize in the misnamed field of economic sciences. Today, we need other pastoralism counternarratives, and even researchers focusing exclusively on the depastoralization of pastoralist societies presumably can esteem that challenge, which she also met.
III.
I type “collapse of pastoralist societies?” into Google search and get this AI-generated answer:
Pastoralist societies have been declining for a variety of reasons, including:
- Lack of government support: Pastoral communities receive little support from their governments.
- Loss of land: Pastoralists have lost access to land due to the development of large-scale cultivation and irrigation, the establishment of nature reserves and game parks, and the imposition of national boundaries.
- Climate change: Climate change has threatened the availability of water and arable land, which are critical for pastoralism.
- Government policies: Governments have expropriated land from pastoralists, and converted communal property systems to open access situations.
- Migration: Some pastoralists have moved to populous areas to pursue education, abandoning traditional lifestyles.
- Conflict: Conflict, disease, drought, and famine have particularly affected vulnerable pastoralist communities.
- Arms proliferation: Arms proliferation has significantly altered the pastoralism landscape.
No surprises here. This is the gist of what we’ve been reading for years. But the obvious question remains: How many pastoralists see this in the same way or for similar reasons?
I don’t know that number, but I most certainly see how some herders believe their pastoralist systems are changing dramatically but nevertheless adhere to a very different narrative of what is going on and being responded to.
–To see how, turn to a recent article that describes the parallel case: Urban people who see it inevitable that modern societies are also collapsing but who act differently than expected.
In his 2024 “The conviction of the inevitable: Collapsism and collective action in contemporary rural France,” Jérôme Tournadre, a political scientist and sociologist, wonders why some people who are totally convinced of the inevitability of collapse in modern (“thermo-industrial”) societies–for them, it’s self-evident the collapse is already underway–respond predictably by moving to the countryside and but then act unexpectedly there. They did not “go back to nature” nor did they eschew all things modern and technological:
Sophie, for example, has no trouble using a thermal brush cutter when it comes to freeing agricultural commons from overly invasive vegetation. Alex earns a little money by occasionally installing photovoltaic panels for individuals. However, he does not see the need to use it at home insofar as his connection to the electricity grid satisfies him. Similarly, if the members of the neo-village [one of the research sites] have chosen to gradually do without cars, it is not to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions but, above all, to no longer depend on oil that is bound to become rare or to lose its usefulness in a collapsed world. This logic obviously leads them to use bicycles but also to learn how to handle and maintain tools such as the scythe, the lumberjack’s handsaw or the Japanese saw that is supposed to replace both the chainsaw and the jigsaw. The acquisition of new skills is in any case a central ambition within these collective actions, which endeavour to break away from the specialization found in industrial civilization and develop a versatility more in line with troubled times: knowing how to milk goats and process their milk, graft fruit trees, recognize wild plants and mushrooms, etc.
Now turn this lens toward pastoralists. Say you do find pastoralists who are convinced that their systems are collapsing and that collapse is inevitable. We nonetheless must ask: So what?
–So yes, pastoralists tell you they now use new tools while acquiring different skills, but still continue to milk the goats, process milk and collect local items. Yes, you see them cutting firewood for cooking but relying on electricity where available. Yes, they readily undertake money-paying jobs off-site to support household livelihoods, including those related to livestock. Yes, you see them breaking away from the specializations of older pastoralisms and developing more versatility and newer options related to that livestock.
Yes, there are pastoralists, like some urbanites, who are alarmed by current events and situations. But their response is more like whistleblowers who still live among us while pressing: “Something’s wrong here and it has to change but here’s what I have to say and here is what’s going right for the time being”



