When prediction is more a genre than anything else

On the contrary, almanacs were one of the most successful genres of the period. At their highest point in the 1660s, sales averaged between 350,000 and 400,000 annually in England, out-selling all other types of books. . . . The suggestions astrologers offered in their printed almanacs for dealing with impending health threats were not ultimately directed at government authorities. To take a modern analogy, almanac prognostications functioned more like WHO press releases containing guidance for the public than reports with advice for state administrators. . . .

M. Pfeffer (2024). “Astrology, plague, and prognostication in early modern England: A forgotten chapter in the history of public health.” Past & Present 263 (1): 81–124 (accessed online at https://academic.oup.com/past/article/263/1/81/7044244)

Appealing to prediction in the midst of collectively-evident turbulence should be read symptomatically in just the above way.

Leave a comment