The continuing challenge to recast the Climate Emergency more complexly and thereby more usefully

Recasting Global Climate Change (GCC). . .

A good deal of my policy analysis has been informed by semiotics and narratology. Someone interested in wicked policy problems (defined as having no beginning or end) is understandably attracted to small-m metanarratives already in the public’s sociolect that can–no guarantees!–recast these problems into more tractable ones without reducing their complexity. Here the search is for what Michel Riffaterre called the intertext(s), which can account for contradictions without dismissing the complexities of the competing stories.

For example, rising sea levels are frequently credited with increased erosion of the coasts and the need for seawalls. But that narrative has to be pushed further. For another story out there today, the GCC modelers’ story, is that rising sea levels also cause increased storm surges and inland flooding (from the increased inland rainfall). When pushed further, the policy implications change (i.e., seawalls can only be part of the response, as erosion increases at and beyond the ends of the seawall?)

What are the intertext(s) that could account for the modelers’ story and all the other stories, for good or bad, about GCC? Riffaterre’s intertext is much like the way A.J. Greimas’s node of “both a and not-a hold at the same time” has been formulated for his semiotic square. To my mind, we are also searching for any policy relevant metanarratives around the “neither a nor not-a” node. That is, are there other language games already out there which would describe what is going on without reducing the complexity of all this, but which really isn’t about “Global Climate Change,” let alone the “Climate Emergency,” as currently described and problematized?

. . .to recasting as Global Climate Sprawl

You get them wrong before you meet them, while you’re anticipating meeting them; you get them wrong while you’re with them; and then you go home to tell somebody else about the meeting and you get them all wrong again. Since the same generally goes for them with you, the whole thing is really a dazzling illusion empty of all perception, an astonishing farce of misperception. And yet. . .It’s getting them wrong that is living, getting them wrong and wrong and wrong and then, on careful reconsideration, getting them wrong again. That’s how we know we’re alive: we’re wrong.

I want to suggest that GCC isn’t just a bad mess; it’s a spectacularly, can’t-keep-our-eyes-off-it, awful mess of doing things wrong, again and again. It’s a hot mess–both senses of the term–now sprawled all over place and time. It is inextricably part and parcel of “living way too expansively, generously.”

GCC’s the demonstration of a stunningly profligate human nature. You see the sheer sprawl of it all in the epigraph, Philip Roth’s rant from American Pastoral. So too the elder statesman in T.S. Eliot’s eponymous play admits,

The many many mistakes I have made
My whole life through, mistake upon mistake,
The mistaken attempts to correct mistakes
By methods which proved to be equally mistaken.

That missing comma between “many many” demonstrates the excess: After a point, we no longer pause, our words and actions rushing ahead. (That the wildly different Philip Roth and T.S. Eliot being together on this point indicates the very real mess it is.)

That earlier word, sprawl, takes us to a more magnanimous view of what is going on, as in Les Murray’s “The Quality of Sprawl”:

Sprawl is the quality
of the man who cut down his Rolls-Royce
into a farm utility truck, and sprawl
is what the company lacked when it made repeated efforts
to buy the vehicle back and repair its image.
Sprawl is doing your farming by aeroplane, roughly,
or driving a hitchhiker that extra hundred miles home…

This extravagance and profligacy–the waste–are not an ornery contrarianism. For poet, Robert Frost, “waste is another name for generosity of not always being intent on our own advantage”. If I had my druthers, rename it, Global Climate Sprawl.

Practically speaking, so what?

To put it succinctly, the proposal here is that the policy agenda for addressing the Climate Emergency establish as its benchmark the really-existing diversity of climate responses and related practices (including militancy) already underway locally. Now that would be radical.

(The more detailed (conventional?) rationale for starting and benchmarking locally can be found in When Complex is as Simple as it Gets: Guide for recasting policy and management in the Anthropocene (Institute of Development Studies, University of Sussex, 2023) https://opendocs.ids.ac.uk/opendocs/handle/20.500.12413/18008)


Leave a Reply